Nightmare Time

Aubrey Plaza

Herself / Julie Jacobs

Jack McBrayer

Mr. McDougal

Pam Murphy

Mrs. McDougal

Lucas Barker

Timmy

Matt Besser

Monica's dad

Nathan Fillion

Himself

Seth Kirschner

Paul

Darcy Fowler

Monica

Eugene Cordero

Drake

Gary Richardson

Turg

Amanda Lund

Alex

Jack

Shit Dog